Home

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Reviews of Street Angel #4

  • Dec. 9th, 2004 at 12:45 PM
logo
There has been an avalanche of reviews of Street Angel #4 by Jim Rugg and Brian Maruca, the issue in which, instead of taking on ninjas, conquistadors or Satanists, Jesse Sanchez tries to survive on the street.

The review at The Pickytarian's Subway Reading (scroll down a bit to see it) is painful -- not because it is negative, but because the reviewer so sadly misses the point, writing, "OK, so Jesse is homeless, and it's sad and difficult. This could have been communicated in less pages, and then there would have been room for some ninja ass-kicking." (Not to descend to picking at grammar but -- oh, hell, let's descend away-- that's fewer pages. Fewer.)

But other reviewers seem to have embraced this issue. Iain Burnside at ComicsNexus, who calls Street Angel "the coolest comic book of the past fifteen years," writes of the "strange, beautiful heart and charm of Street Angel." Ray Tate at Silver Bullet Comics catches the humor that is still present in this issue and comments that Jim and Brian "eschew symbolism to ground the story in reality." Jog the Blog (scroll down a bit) notes the "majestic" quality of the opening pages, in which Street Angel's heroic introduction is "broken up into small captions, impotently dotting several full-page splashes of finely-detailed ruin, of total powerlessness." At ComiX-Fan, Ryan Day succinctly tells us just what this issue is all about: "This is a story about a girl who’s on her own and doesn’t have anything to eat, and it’s amazingly humanizing in its simplicity."

Oooh, oooh -- now me! This issue is understated and nuanced in its storytelling, and absolutely gorgeous in its artwork. I know I'm supposed to say stuff like that, but I really, really mean it. It is an issue that Jim and Brian have been working toward: You get glimpses of the part of Jesse's life that isn't spent in heroics in other issues, such as her friend's comment that Jesse hasn't been in school in some time in issue one, Jesse reading Charlotte's Web and bumming a smoke in issue two, and a glimpse at her vulnerabily in issue three; but in issue four, you truly get to meet not just the nigh-invicible, wise-cracking Street Angel, but the girl herself -- Jesse Sanchez.

-Jennifer "Weepy" de Guzman
e-i-c

EDIT: Also, check out the sculpture of Jesse Sanchez that Jesse Farrell is working on -- there are links to it here.

Comments

[info]lordpyrate wrote:
Dec. 9th, 2004 01:24 pm (UTC)
No, this was the perfect restoration of balance after the ninjas and conquistadors and Satan. Jesse fights evil, but she is a street person. To be able to so clearly show the disparity in the worlds she lives in (one minute fending off an Earth-threatening force and the next trying to hide from a girl in her class so her shameful poverty isn't exposed) is the hallmark of creators who strive for more than the status quo (not to mention rare talent). I didn't know, before the issue came out, whether or not we'd ever be taken down this road, but I can say now that we have that I am extremely grateful. I used to be able to cheer for Jesse; now I can believe in her, too.

(Also, the ninja advice on catching the arrow was very practical.)

Latest Month

July 2009
S M T W T F S
   1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031 

Tags

Page Summary

Add to Google

Add to Technorati Favorites



website metrics
Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Jared MacPherson